infrogmation: (Default)
Personal retrospective anniversary post - adapted from my old LiveJournal (migrated to Dreamwidth) post on the 1st anniversary, as I was too busy experiencing it to post about it at the time, with a few slight edits and some relevant photos added.

----

To backtrack just before...

Beverly, an old friend and former New Orleanian, and her sweetie, Girgl, the professor of physics from Germany, were staying at my place. The previous day other old friends were passing through town, Nancy & Harrison, moving out of Bay St. Louis on the Mississippi coast up to Arkansas. We and some other acquaintances all went to lunch at Sid-Mar's, on the Bucktown peninsula where the 17th Street Canal meets Lake Pontchartrain. (Spoiler, I mention this place specifically as less than a week later everything in the area would be gone.)

Ruins with bits of concrete stairs and random objects
Photo by Infrogmation: What was left of Bucktown after we got back to town from evacuation.

My car brakes were sticking, I said maybe I should take it by a mechanic in the morning. Girgl said he'd take a look at it. He jammed the brake pedal hard and it stopped sticking. He said it was likely just a pebble caught in the mechanism, but it was fine now.

The tv news reported a category 1 hurricane named Katrina was heading towards the Florida Panhandle.

At night we had dinner at Mandina's in Mid City. (Spoiler, in a few days Mid-City New Orleans would be inundated in the Federal Flood when the levee system failed in the biggest engineering disaster in US history.)

Friday morning, 26 August 2005, I'd listened to the news on the radio this morning and not heard of any change about the hurricane.

I picked up my new business cards, the first ever with my just acquired self-phone number. I'd be leading my new band at the Miss Crescent City pageant the following day. I stopped by the Unitarian Church on Claiborne where the pageant would be. Ms Hollie was one of the organizers, and I checked out the venue and looked in on some of the rehearsal.

interior of flood damaged church
Another view of interior of flood damaged Church

Photos by Ms Hollie: Interior of the Unitarian Universalist Church after we got back from evacuation.


Friday night I was playing trombone as a substitute with a jazz band on Decatur Street in the Quarter.

On break, a tourist remarked how much fun they were having, and they'd managed to change their flight to leave early the next day. Why's that, I asked. The hurricane is coming! Hurricane? Others who'd heard more recent news confirmed that Katrina had changed course and strengthened and was a potential threat to New Orleans. Might come here sometime after the weekend.

Saturday the 27th Ms Hollie and I were both in a bit of a tizzy. The morning news showed the storm looking even worse. Hollie was taking care of Pageant details, and I was taking care of things regarding the band, while contemplating that we may need to evacuate. I picked up the sandwiches for the band, unsuccessfully looking to fill my gas tank on the way-- stations either had long lines or had signs announcing they were out of gas. The band's drummer, Sue, called to say she couldn't make it as she'd been called to the State Museum to do their hurricane battoning down the hatches procedure. I unsuccessfully tried to get a sub, calling around thinking, "Oh no! A hurricane is coming, and I have to find a drummer!"

The band members -- sans drummer-- met at the trumpeter's house in Broadmoor, a short distance from the venue. (Spoiler, Broadmoor would soon be under deep water.) We'd planned to do a quick rehearsal, as the musicians I'd gathered had never played together as a group. We did no rehearsing, instead staring at the tv screen with a satellite image of a monster that seemed more than half the size of the whole Gulf of Mexico barrelling towards us.

On to the pageant. The band played some to fill time before anything else got started; Ms Hollie revealed that the MC didn't come into town from the North Shore due to the hurricane, and things had to be rearranged. The turn out was light but things went well considering the improvised nature. Fortunately the guitar and tuba were such good rhythm players that we overcame the lack of a drummer.

Before and after playing, the sax player, who managed a convenience store in the 7th Ward, was on his phone trying to finagle or bribe a gasoline tanker truck to make a run into town as the store had emptied their gas tanks early that morning. He was also instructing the staff to turn the freezer to maximum setting and put the perishables in it, as there might be a power outage. (Spoiler, this area of the 7th Ward would soon be in deep water.)


Aerial photo of flooded cityscape
Photo by Jocelyn Augustino/FEMA, Aerial photo over the 7th Ward area 30 August 2005


After the pageant the co-organizer Margaret was going to drive straight to Dallas, and tried to foist off a whole pile of perishable food on Hollie and me. As I was trying to empty the refrigerator of perishables, most went right into a trash bag and the trash can. (Alas, the emptying of the fridge was not nearly complete enough, as would be revealed over 5 weeks later.)

Sue phoned to say the museum staff had made quick work of things and she was already in her car on the road to Texas.

I finally found an open gas station with not too terrible a line (they only had super; my car takes regular, but this wasn't the time to be too picky.)

Bev & Girgl were off somewhere (I later found another friend was taking them on a driving tour all around town-- in retrospect, very fitting). I closed up the house's storm shutters and packed up suitcases-- what we needed, then extra space filled with local collectables like jazzfest and art opening shirts.

Hollie and I then tried to unwind with a splash in the back yard inflatable pool and lying in the sun a bit-- it was a very beautiful late afternoon. Somehow, however, it seemed strangely quiet. I didn't realize until hearing other folks accounts later that most of the birds had already left town.

The Krewe of OAK Midsummer Mardi Gras Parade was in my neighborhood that night. Hollie and I were throwing together costumes when Bev & Girgl came back. I told them a major hurricane was coming, and they needed to pack up-- I'd check the weather service website at dawn, and if the storm hadn't changed course, they needed to get out. Girgl said, "This hurricane sounds very interesting. I have never seen one. I think I would like to stay and watch it."

".... No." I replied. "No, you don't. Nancy and Harrison want you to visit them in Arkansas; this is the time to go there."

We all went to OAK. The turn out was lighter than usual; many folks had already left town. We heard Mayor Nagin had issued a call for a voluntary evacuation. Some friends said they'd spent the day boarding up their house and packing, and planned to drive out after the party. One costumer had "KATRINA STAY AWAY" painted on them. It was a good parade party.

Woman and man in colorful robes; man holds a digital camera
Beverly and Girgl at Krewe of OAK Mid-Summer 2005

2 women in colorful costumes on dark street
Hollie and reveler at Krewe of OAK Mid-Summer 2005

Dancing in the street
Dancing in the streets of New Orleans, maybe for the last time, before evacuating.

Krewe of OAK Mid-Summer Mardi Gras 2005 photos by Infrogmation


Back home. Hollie needed to pick up her cell phone charger on the West Bank before leaving town. I said I didn't want to fight traffic in the morning; let's do it now. Traffic was light after midnight. Along Claiborne and Fountainebleau hundreds of cars were already parked up on the raised neutral grounds in hopes that the half foot of added elevation would protect them if there was flooding. (Spoiler, it wouldn't. )

We all got up before dawn on Sunday 28 August. Bev and Girgl drove out of town just before dawn. Hollie and I headed out about 40 minutes later, after I spent some time anxiously pacing around the house, double checking things, and throwing a few more possessions into the car.

Between the speed of the arrival of the storm and being busy, unlike evacuations for Andrew and Ivan I had no reservations nor definite destination. Maybe to my Brother in Gainesville, my parents who were staying in Jacksonville, or see if we can get a room somewhere beyond Tallahassee... just bug out. We headed east on I-10, on the high rise across the open water of the Rigoletts. Traffic was heavy but moving through Slidell, then pretty good thereafter. My car radio didn't work, but Hollie brought a portable. Somewhere in Mississippi we heard Mayor Nagin had made the evacuation mandatory, the first in the city's history. I was having a problem with my car's brakes-- every time I'd use them, they'd stick worse. It wasn't just a pebble, clearly. I had to jam on them repeatedly to get them unstuck. I tried to not worry Hollie by talking about the problem as an amusing minor annoyance, but she was not fooled.

At Tallahassee we stopped to eat and make some calls. My mother had already made us reservations in Jacksonville! She said she saw an ad in the paper with a good rate at the local Quality Inn, so she booked it. Peachy, thanks!

We made it to Jacksonville. I followed the directions-- it turns out it wasn't a Quality Inn as my mother thought, it was the "OK Quality Motel" or some such-- we looked at the room and the Quality was low indeed as fleas bit our ankles. We succeeded in finding a vacancy at a better motel nearby, and used one of the obvious defects of the room as an excuse to cancel the reservation at the first place.

The next morning, Monday the 29th, at the complementary motel breakfast the lobby tv was on showing satellite images of the hurricane coming ashore at South East Louisiana. One fellow evacuee from the area was for some reason insisting that the storm wasn't going to be hitting shore until that evening (I think that had been the prediction a day or so earlier, but the tv was clearly showing otherwise). I was trying to find a brake repair place when my parents arranged to move us to a better hotel-- with internet access (Yay). We repacked and moved to the other hotel. As we were unpacking the car Hollie got a call from Tal, who said he heard a report of those dreaded words: a levee break. A bit later, a report mentioned flooding somewhere in the 9th Ward. "Sounds like a rerun of Betsy", I sighed.

I took the car to get the brakes fixed. When it was ready, the mechanics wanted to joke at length that the Superdome now had a new skylight.

And so began my evacuation.
infrogmation: (Default)
20 years ago this week I got my first mobile phone. I've upgraded once since (when the old flip phone finally died in 2020).

August 2005 I was fairly active playing trombone, with a weekly gig, a monthy gig, a gig that was a successful tryout for another weekly gig to start the following month, a private party, 2 special events, and at least 1 gig as a substitute.

Then at the end of the month, a notorious rude interruption.

I kept this my old LJ (migrated to Dreamwith) in no small part for the documentation of my life before, during and after the disaster.

I see on social media various locals talking about the anniversary bringing up PTSD.
All of us who went through it have that. In various degrees and manifesting in different ways, but I don't think there were any exceptions.

There's a 5 part National Geographic documentary "Hurricane Katrina - Race Against Time" that's supposed to be very good, and I plan to watch it; I read it's on Hulu and probably elsewhere.
Some find it best for their mental health to avoid such things.
I was one who dealt with things by diving in. Perhaps the less common reaction, but far from alone.

Beyond basic survival, I channeled my energies into documenting the situation and finding out what happened, fueled by righteous indignation and intellectual curiosity, and armed with my skills in historical research and a pocket digital camera I got while evacuated in Texas.

I got the camera intending to document damage to my own home and those of some friends who couldn't get back so soon and asked me to email them photos of how their homes looked. Soon, however, it became clear that more was needed, as stories in the national media were often clearly wrong. I'd participated in Wikipedia and Wikimedia before the Federal Flood, but dove in deep afterwards.

----

I recall when evacuating for Hurricane Gustav in 2008, feeling that if New Orleans were destroyed, my taking part in rebuilding, even though at that point very incompletely, was probably the most important thing I'd done in my life - helping New Orleans exist for a couple more years.

-----

Effects on mental health vary from person to person.

Suicidal depression ran in my family, and I'd fought it myself, going back to childhood.
I've not had such episodes since, even when going through some very bad situations.
I think it's related to seeing such widespread disaster, and knowing in comparison that my own problems didn't amount to anything much. Although I'd understood that intellectually, it seems to have taken this disaster to understand it viscerally.
infrogmation: (Default)
The effects of Hurricane Sandy have of course been on my mind. I've not been sure what to say about it - of course, sympathy for those affected, and various striking similarities and striking differences compared with what the central Gulf Coast experienced in 2005.

All too familiar are the images of masses of flood totaled automobiles, flooded homes and businesses, worse effected neighborhoods totally smashed to rubble, more intact neighborhoods without electricity, blocks of buildings burned down. MREs, very long lines for gasoline when there was any at all.

No shortage of differences, big and small.

Some post-Katrina tips don't seem relevant here, like if your fridge had anything in it when you evacuated, after 40 days without power in hot summer heat, don't think of trying to open it, just tape the door shut and haul it to the curb (and use it as a billboard to write your frustrations on).

Greater New York didn't have a Federal anti-flood system that was supposed to prevent the worst of the damage but experienced at slew of catastrophic failures when put to the test.

Going through a major disaster is damn unpleasant and a long term inconvenience no matter what the circumstances. But getting water, food, and basic survival supplies to those in need, as opposed to not doing so even when there was capability to do so, makes a huge difference. There used to be a bipartisan consensus on this. I hope there will be again henceforth.

Here's what Paul Krugman says in the New York Times:

"Sandy Versus Katrina" by Paul Krugman, New York Times

Mirror of text behind cut )
infrogmation: (Default)
Today is 6 years since Hurricane Katrina hit the Louisiana/Mississippi coast, and Greater New Orleans was struck by the accompanying unnatural disaster of the greatest engineering failure in U.S. history.

Lady Liberty Floodlines 1Lower 9th 14 Dec Debris E car

Katrina Irish Bayou Hymel Cross 2
All We Have Left


So, what's in the news on the 6th anniversary of the Great Levee Failure?


Times-Picayune:New Orleans levees get a near-failing grade in new corps rating system

6 Flags Have A Great Day Floodlines
infrogmation: (Default)
Like more than 80% + of the population of the city, I bugged out just in advance of Hurricane Katrina 5 years ago. Those who didn't, and lived to tell about it, often have some interesting stories. Hundreds, maybe thousands, of these stories have made it into print, web sites and blogs. Hundreds of thousands more stories haven't. Below are a few excerpts from some of the many stories I've heard from friends, acquaintances, other New Orleanians I've talked with.
Read more... )
infrogmation: (Default)
Times-Picayune photographer John McCusker's Katrina story and photographs.

Through the Eye of Katrina - John McCusker
infrogmation: (Default)
Harry Shearer in the Huffington Post:Another Katrina Myth Busted...by Science Text mirrored below; the original also has links to source articles.
----

NEW ORLEANS -- Today in this city, the Presidential Commission looking into the Deepwater Horizon disaster is holding its first meeting. Quick question: how quickly after the water receded in the 2005 New Orleans flood did that Presidential commission hold its first meeting? Answer: never, there was no such commission.

So the truth about the disastrous flooding of this city has dribbled out slowly, piecemeal, over the intervening years, ignored by all but a few outside Orleans Parish.

First, there were the early reports from the two independent forensic engineering teams looking into the cause of the flooding (ILIT and Team Louisiana), investigations which would prove that the flooding was a man-made, not natural, disaster. Then, we learned that the early, frantic rumors -- spread by, among others, the former Mayor and police chief on Oprah's show -- of horrors in the Superdome and Convention Center were wildly overstated if not completely fictitious.

Today comes the latest busting of a long-prevalent Katrina-era myth, courtesy of a report in the Times-Picayune. It debunks the myth of the floodwaters as being a "toxic gumbo". Specifically, the report -- by researchers from Colorado State and Tulane -- found that the lead level in New Orleans soil, historically high due to the use of lead paint and leaded gasoline, plummeted after the flood, as did the lead levels in children's blood.

As we approach the five-year anniversary of the flooding next month, it becomes increasingly clear that almost every piece of information spread about the event by the national media has turned out to be, to use a term of journalistic art, wrong.
infrogmation: (Default)
Some background to illustrate a point relevent to my previous post.

New Orleans hundreds of years of history has multiple examples of floods from semi-tropical downpours, hurricanes, and levee failures.




What happened in 2005 was radically different.



More illustrated history )

In short:

There's a difference between a flood that gets your feet wet in the street



And one that drowns you in your attic.



Heck of a job, MRGO.
infrogmation: (Default)
"It has been proven in a court of law that the drowning of New Orleans was not a natural disaster, but a preventable man-made travesty," the attorneys said in a statement. "The government has always had a moral obligation to rebuild New Orleans. This decision makes that obligation a matter of legal responsibility." -- CNN story

Here in Greater New Orleans, where people routinely talk about "the Federal Flood" and refer to the MRGO Canal as "the Hurricane Highway", the news isn't the facts of the case, but rather the judge finding legal liability.

If I understand the ruling correctly, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has legal immunity from being sued for damages from the failure of their mis-designed and mis-built levees, but not for the fact that the MRGO Canal channeled deep sea storm surge right into the heart of the city. This point alone is enough to make them culpable for the majority of the flooding of the Greater New Orleans area in 2005.

Times-Picayume story

On Bloomberg

On UPI

WDSU, with link to PDF of lawsuit

For those interested in details of what happened and why concerning the great flood, I reccomend the book Catastrophe in the Making: The Engineering of Katrina and the Disasters of Tomorrow. It also makes the point that rather than Greater New Orleans being unique in vulnerability, bad decisions by political and business interests have created no shortage of other engineering disasters waiting to happen.
YouTube video of one of the co-authors and members of levees.org at a reading/discussion at Octavia Books.

Links

Aug. 28th, 2009 08:46 am
infrogmation: (Default)
Snarky but interesting early look at next year's mayor race in New Orleans:

The Root: "Who Will Run New Orleans?" by Eli Ackerman

Video by John McCusker, done for the Katrina anniversary last year. Reposted "because little has changed since then":

Times-Picayune Video: Ghosts of Katrina

New look at Memorial Hospital during the great levee failure disaster:

New York Times: Strained by Katrina, a Hospital Faced Deadly Choices

Why do Republicans Hate Our Troops, latest episode:

Veterans for Common Sense: Veterans Demand Apology from GOP and FOX for Lies About VA
infrogmation: (Default)
Coming up to the 4th anniversary of the worst disaster to hit a U.S. city in 99 years. New Orleans population has rebounded to some 3/4 of its pre-K level, and local culture is in a number of ways thriving, it seems to me in no small part in an act of deliberate defiance. In governmental response, however, "Heck of a Job" remains the unfortunate rule. Various details:

"Katrina Cottages": some finally under construction in Louisiana; none yet occupied by anyone who lost their home.

Delgado College lost its library in the Katrina levee failure flooding. FEMA promised funds to restore the building and restock with books. The library building is still empty.

Times-Picayune today: FEMA & Coast Guard to get to work clearing up some 6,000 Katrina sunk boats and other objects clogging waterways in S. Louisiana

Levees.org: Saying Katrina destroyed New Orleans is like saying traffic destroyed the Minneapolis bridge

Guardian: Four years on, Katrina remains cursed by rumour, cliche, lies and racism. Ordinary people mostly behaved well. Those in power panicked, spread fear and fiction, and showed eagerness to kill
infrogmation: (Default)


29 August 2005: President George W. Bush takes a break from his vacation to fly out to Phoenix for the birthday of his pal Senator John McCain.


Do you remember where you were, what you were doing, how you felt on August 29th 2005? If you live in a section of the USA about the size of Britain, stretching from the western Florida Panhandle to past Grand Isle Louisiana and a long bit inland, you probably remember it all too well.

If you lived in other parts of the country, you may have noticed something about it on the news. Hurricane Katrina.



Bush & McCain FAILED to defend America )
infrogmation: (Default)
H and I are contemplating it might be road trip time again, as Hurricane Gustav is forcasted to be heading to the central Gulf Coast.

I've never seen so much activity while a storm was this far out before. There were lines at gas stations in Chalmette 2 days ago and some buildings Uptown being boarded up yesterday. While I always keep an eye on storm threats, the early track projections heading straight towards us didn't worry me much, as one thing I don't recall any hurricane doing is continuing in a straight line for 6 days.

I'll be keeping an eye on the National Hurricane Center website, and the birds. The birds bugged out the Saturday before Katrina; if they go I'm not sticking around. Rumors have it that Da Mayor may issue an evacuation order way early and at lower hit possibility than Ivan etc.

Of course people here have their minds on the terrible scenes from this time 3 years ago







The horror... the horror...
infrogmation: (Default)
Salon.com article "How Karl Rove played politics while people drowned".

Lots of confirmation of stuff those of us who've kept a close eye things already knew, but some new details.

Favorite detail I didn't already know: Gov. Blanco personally gave President Bush a two-page letter detailing everything the state needed to cope with the disaster. Bush "lost" the letter. Ooopsie.

Text mirror )

McCain said

Jun. 3rd, 2008 08:45 pm
infrogmation: (Default)
"We must also prepare, far better than we have, to respond quickly and effectively to a natural calamity. When Americans confront a catastrophe they have a right to expect basic competence from their government. Firemen and policemen should be able to communicate with each other in an emergency. We should be able to deliver bottled water to dehydrated babies and rescue the infirm from a hospital with no electricity. Our disgraceful failure to do so here in New Orleans exposed the incompetence of government at all levels to meet even its most basic responsibilities." -- John McCain

Applause. I'm not planning to vote for McCain, and I may never applaud him again, but he earned my applause for saying this.

Though he said it not "here in New Orleans" but 2 cities over in Kenner, Louisiana.

Also, contrary to the McCain campaign official transcript above, he spoke it as "deliver hot bottled water to dehydrated babies". Whatever.

And more importantly, as bad as the "natural calamity" was, the man-made one was very much worse.

And McCain twice voted against establishing a Congressional commission to examine Federal, State, and local response to devastation wrought by Hurricane Katrina. He also voted against emergency relief after the disaster, funding communications for disaster first reponders, and other relevent items.

Perhaps you think such proposals should be opposed on the grounds of keeping the government small.

Perhaps you think William Howard Taft was a damn Commie for authorizing the army to bring food and tents to San Francisco after the great earthquake.

Perhaps you think when the shit hits the fan, it is better to let our citizens die of from lack basic necessities than to spend government funds to save their lives. Maybe you have no problem with America being a country whose government leaves the corpses of its people who die unnecessarily bloated in the sun, to be eaten by rats and dogs.

If so, I disagree with you. But I'd have a modicum more respect for you had the courage to damn well admit it.

December 2025

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
2122 232425 2627
28 2930 31   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jan. 6th, 2026 02:44 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios